During our conversation James Buddy Day, Director of the NOFX documentary 40 Years of Fuckin’ Up, he opened up about digging through decades of chaotic archival footage, navigating the unpredictable world of NOFX, his background in true crime documentaries, and why DIY creativity still matters more than ever.
Digging Through 40 Years of Punk History
One of the most eye-opening parts of 40 Years of Fuckin’ Up is the amount of archival footage packed into the film.
From grimy backstage clips to emotionally raw and vulnerable moments, the documentary feels less like a traditional music documentary and according to Day, there was a lot to sort through.
“So much archival footage,” I called out during the interview, reflecting on just how deep the rabbit hole went.
The process ultimately took around two years to complete, condensing four decades of punk rock history into a single documentary experience. Definitely, not exactly a small task.
More Than a Punk Documentary
What makes 40 Years of Fuckin’ Up stand out is that it doesn’t feel overly sanitized or manufactured. The film embraces the chaos, contradictions, humor, and darker moments that come with a band like NOFX.
Buddy Day discussed how his background in true crime storytelling influenced the structure and tone of the documentary, bringing a more layered and human perspective to the project instead of simply creating a highlight reel. That’s honestly what made this documentary hit hard.
That emotional honesty is exactly why the theatrical screenings have resonated so strongly with audiences.
We specifically pointed out how powerful it felt watching the documentary in a packed theater, hearing collective reactions from fans in real time, almost like attending a punk show itself. Buddy Day mentioned that the goal was to make fans feel like they just attended a NOFX concert and he accomplished that with this documentary.
Working With NOFX
Making a film about NOFX also comes with its own set of challenges. During the interview, we jokingly pointed out:
“You’re not gonna get what you need when you need it… but you’re gonna get it, right?” Chris asked.
Day laughed in agreement because if there’s one thing synonymous with NOFX, it’s unpredictability.
Beneath the chaos, the documentary still manages to capture the humanity behind the band members, something Day clearly values deeply in his filmmaking approach. Let’s be real, his style and talent is exemplified in the way he showcases his subjects in a raw and unapologetic way, humanizing every aspect, while invoking a variety of emotions from viewers.
DIY Ethics Still Matter
One of the strongest moments in the conversation came when Day gave advice to aspiring filmmakers and directors.
His philosophy? Just start creating.
The DIY spirit that fueled punk rock scenes for decades still applies directly to filmmaking today. Whether it’s music, documentaries, or storytelling in general, waiting for permission is often the fastest way to never create anything at all.
That mentality connects perfectly with NOFX’s legacy, a band that built an empire outside traditional industry systems.
The True Crime Connection
Outside of punk rock documentaries, Day also discussed his experiences working in the true crime world, including conversations surrounding Charles Manson.
The conversation shifted into the psychology behind infamous criminals, manipulation, prison systems, and the strange phenomenon of serial killer fandoms, topics Day approached with curiosity rather than sensationalism.
What became clear throughout the interview is that Day is drawn toward complicated human stories, whether they involve punk bands, cult leaders, or deeply flawed public figures.
That curiosity is part of what gives his work depth.
Capturing the Human Side of Punk
At its core, 40 Years of Fuckin’ Up succeeds because it doesn’t try to mythologize NOFX into untouchable rock stars.
Instead, it captures them as messy, funny, self-destructive, creative, complicated human beings.
And James Buddy Day seems perfectly comfortable sitting inside that chaos long enough to find the truth buried underneath it.
Which honestly feels very punk rock in itself.
Follow James Buddy Day:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jamesbuddyday/
Youtube: Unmarked Podcast
Podcast: https://tr.ee/TL2muWsd4p
Watch the documentary: https://www.40yearsoffuckinup.com/
If you enjoyed this post, check out our NOFX documentary premiere recap:
About C² (Christy + Chris)
Concert lovers turned creators. Highlighting creators, bands, stories, sounds, and places you need to know.
Disarray Magazine is an independent media platform established in 2009, spotlighting punk, hardcore, alternative culture, live music, food, nightlife, and the chaos in between. Created by journalist Christy Buena, C² exists to document the bands, people, and moments shaping the scene.
Leave a Reply